top of page
inline-wordmarks.png
menu-button.png

Brand Values: What They Are and How to Define Yours

Writer: Skyler Hibicki
Skyler Hibicki
Sep 27
10 min read

You started your business because something in you needed to. You built it from nothing, and it carries your fingerprints. So here's a question worth sitting with: when someone lands on your website, do they feel what you stand for, or do they only see what you sell?


That gap, between what you care about and what comes across, is where brand values do their quiet work. They're not corporate fluff. For a small, heart-led business, they're the compass that keeps everything you make pointing the same direction.


TL;DR


  • Brand values are the core beliefs that guide how you run your business and show up for the people you serve.

  • They're not your mission (what you do) or your vision (where you're headed). They sit underneath both.

  • Clear values make your decisions faster, draw in the right people, and build trust over time.

  • You don't need a boardroom to find them, just honesty about what lights you up and what you refuse to compromise on.

  • Narrow to three to five, write them in plain language, and let them shape everything from your logo to your homepage.


What Brand Values Actually Are


Your brand values are the handful of beliefs that sit underneath every decision your business makes. They're the reasons behind the reasons:


  • Why you price the way you do.

  • Why you say no to certain projects.

  • Why your website feels warm instead of clinical, or bold instead of safe.


Think of them less as words on a page and more as a filter. When a decision comes up, a clear value tells you which way to lean without a long debate:


  • Do we take this client?

  • Do we cut this corner to save a week?

  • Do we chase the trend or hold our ground?


Values answer those questions before you have to.


Here's the part most people miss. A value only counts if it costs you something. "Quality" isn't really a value if you'd never knowingly choose the cheaper, faster, worse option anyway. A real value shows up in the moments where honoring it is harder than ignoring it.


For a small business, this matters even more than it does for a big one. A large company has layers of process to keep it consistent. You have you. Your values are the thing that keeps your business steady when you're tired, busy, or tempted by a shortcut.


Two colleagues collaborate at a desk with two laptops, one pointing at a screen while the other works, surrounded by sticky notes and a notebook.

Brand Values Versus Mission, Vision, and Voice


These four get tangled together constantly, so let's untangle them. They're related, but they do different jobs.


Your mission is what you do and who you do it for, right now. The U.S. Small Business Administration suggests putting a mission statement near the very top of a business plan, in the executive summary, precisely because it tells the reader what your company is in a sentence or two.


Your vision is where you're headed. It's the future you're building toward, the change you want to see because your business exists.


Your brand voice is how you sound when you talk. Warm or wry, plain or poetic, calm or electric. Voice is the personality your words carry.


Your brand values sit underneath all three. Your mission, your vision, and your voice all flow out of what you actually believe. When someone asks me to help them find their voice and their values feel fuzzy, we start with the values every time, because you can't sound like yourself until you know what "yourself" stands for.


Why Brand Values Matter for a Small Business


It would be easy to file brand values under "nice to have" and get back to the real work. I'd gently push back on that. For a small, personal business, values are some of the most practical tools you have. Three payoffs matter most:


  • Faster decisions. Running a business is a thousand small choices a week, and decision fatigue is real. When you know that "accessibility" is a value, you don't relitigate whether to caption your videos every time. Values turn a hundred future arguments into one decision you made on purpose, ahead of time.


  • The right people. I'd rather you attract 20 people who feel completely seen by your brand than 200 who scroll right past it. The right presence repels as intentionally as it attracts. And this is not a shrinking niche: across 25 countries in Ipsos Global Trends 2021, an average of 70 percent of people said they buy from brands they believe reflect their own principles, and in the US that figure climbed from 50 percent in 2013 to 66 percent in 2021.


  • Trust that compounds. Trust isn't built in a single visit. It's built by showing up the same way until people can predict you. Nielsen Norman Group's research on trustworthy web design found that the factors people use to judge credibility, like a cared-for design and honest, upfront information, have stayed stable since 1999. Values are how you stay consistent long enough for that trust to form.


Brand Values Examples for Creative Small Businesses


Most articles on this topic reach for the giants. Patagonia and the environment. A big hotel chain and its five corporate pillars. Those are fine, but they're not you, and copying a Fortune 500 value set is a fast way to sound like everyone else. So here are the kinds of values I see doing real work for the creative, service, and maker businesses I design for, and how each one shows up in practice.


  • Craftsmanship, for a maker or product business. It shows up in materials you won't cut, in photography that honors the detail, in a shop page that tells you how a thing was made rather than only what it costs.

  • Groundedness, for a wellness practitioner. It shows up in a calm, uncluttered website, in unhurried copy, in booking that feels like an exhale instead of a sales funnel.

  • Playfulness, for a food cart or an event business. It shows up in bright color, in copy that has a sense of humor, in a brand that doesn't take itself too seriously because the experience it sells is joy.

  • Belonging, for a community or nonprofit organization. It shows up in inclusive language, in imagery that reflects the actual people served, in accessibility treated as a baseline and not a bonus.

  • Honesty, for a coach or consultant. It shows up in plain pricing, in a homepage that describes real outcomes without hype, in the willingness to say who you're not the right fit for.


Notice that none of these are impressive on their own. The word isn't the point. What makes a value real is that you can see it in the work. If someone could visit your website and correctly guess your values without you listing them, you've done it right.


Two people sit at a dark table with notebooks, a smartphone, a pen, and sticky notes during a collaborative meeting in a professional workspace.

How to Define Your Brand Values


You don't need a strategy offsite or a committee to find your values. Most of my clients are one person, sometimes two, and we find them in a single honest conversation. Here's the process I walk people through, and you can do it on your own with a notebook and an afternoon. Work through it in order.


1. Look at What Lights You Up


Start with evidence, not aspiration. Think back over the projects, clients, or days that left you energized instead of drained. What did they have in common? The thread running through your favorite work is usually a value hiding in plain sight. My own philosophy grew straight out of this: when you find what lights you up and serve others with it, you naturally reach the right people.


2. Notice Your Non-Negotiables


Now the flip side. Think of a time you felt that quiet no in your chest, a project or a request you turned down even though the money was good. What line were you protecting? Those lines are your values with the volume turned up. The things you refuse to bend on tell you more than the things you say you care about.


3. Name the Feeling


Close your eyes and picture someone leaving an interaction with your business, a purchase, a session, a first look at your site. How do you want them to feel? Seen. Calm. Delighted. Capable. That feeling is downstream of a value, and naming it helps you find the belief underneath.


4. Narrow to Three to Five


You'll probably end up with a messy list of ten or twelve words. Good. Now cut. Group the ones that are really saying the same thing, and keep the truest word from each cluster. Three to five is the sweet spot. Fewer than three and your brand feels thin. More than five and none of them are memorable, least of all to you.


5. Write Them in Plain Language


Finally, give each value a full sentence rather than a bare label. "Craftsmanship" means little on its own. "We'd rather ship a week late than ship something we are not proud of" means everything. Plain language keeps a value honest and keeps it usable, because you can actually check a decision against a full sentence.


How to Live Your Brand Values Across Your Brand and Website


Defining your values is the easy half. The hard half is letting them show. A value that lives only on a page titled "Our Values" isn't really a value yet. It has to travel into the parts of your brand people actually touch.


This is the piece the internet usually skips. Most advice tells you to post your values on social media and leave it there. But for a small business, your website and your visual brand carry your values far more than a caption ever will. Nielsen Norman Group puts it well: the company owns a brand, the designer reinforces it, and the customer interprets it. In other words, what you intend doesn't matter until it shows up in the experience. If the experience doesn't match what you promised, the brand is compromised.


So let your values steer the concrete choices. Here is where a few common values should actually be felt:


If your value is

Here's where people should feel it

A certain mood (grounded or electric)

Your color palette

Craft and care for detail

Your fonts and photography

Respect for the reader

Homepage copy that validates before it ever asks for the sale

Accessibility

A palette built to meet accessibility standards, and a site that works for everyone who lands on it

Belonging

Said out loud, somewhere people can find it



This is exactly why I publish a belonging statement on my own site and signed the Good Apples pledge. I want the people who work with me to know what I stand for before we ever hop on a call, because that clarity is part of the work. As a Certified Wix Studio Expert, I spend a lot of my day translating a founder's values into the small design decisions that make a website feel unmistakably like them. Beautiful design that doesn't connect is just art. Strategy without beauty is forgettable. The magic is where they meet, and that's exactly where values earn their keep.


When you book a custom brand identity, the whole point is to carry one clear set of values through your logo, your palette, your type, and your site, so nothing contradicts anything else. That consistency is what makes a small brand feel bigger than its size.


Common Mistakes That Make Brand Values Fall Flat


A few patterns show up again and again when values aren't working. Watch for these.


  • Choosing values that please everyone. If your values could belong to any business in your industry, they're not doing their job. Values should draw a line, not smooth one over.

  • Picking words you admire but don't live. Aspiration is lovely, but a value you don't actually honor becomes a promise you break in public. Choose what is true now, and let the aspirational ones be goals instead.

  • Writing them once and filing them away. Values are a working tool, not a plaque. If you never look at them when you make a real decision, they'll drift out of the business without you noticing.

  • Keeping them a secret. Values you never express can't attract anyone. Put them where people can feel them, in your copy, your design, and the way you talk about your work.

  • Stopping at a list. A word is a starting point. The value isn't real until it changes something a visitor can actually see and feel.


A person in an orange shirt holds a ribbed glass while standing next to a person in a white t-shirt who is looking at a black smartphone in hand.

Frequently Asked Questions


A few more questions I hear often from owners defining their brand values for the first time.


What is the difference between brand values and core values?


In practice, most small businesses use the two terms to mean the same thing, and that's fine. If you want to draw a line, core values tend to describe how the people inside the business behave, while brand values describe what the business stands for in the eyes of the people it serves. For a one-person business, they're usually identical, because you're the culture and the brand at the same time.


How many brand values should a small business have?


Three to five is the range I recommend. That's enough to capture what makes you distinct without diluting into a list nobody can remember. If you can't recite your own values from memory, you have too many. Pick the truest few and let the rest go.


Do brand values matter for a one-person business?


Yes, arguably more than they do for a large one. When you're the whole business, your values are the only thing keeping your brand consistent across a busy, tiring week. They're also what let a customer feel like they know you before they have met you, which is most of the reason someone chooses a small, personal business over a faceless one.


Can my brand values change over time?


They can, and often they should. I rebranded my own studio after a season of real inner work changed what I wanted my business to stand for. Your values should evolve as you do. The goal isn't to lock them in forever. It's to be honest about what is true now, and to update your brand when the truth shifts.


Build a Brand Around What You Value


Your brand values aren't something you have to invent. They're already there, in the work that lights you up and the lines you refuse to cross. The work is naming them, narrowing them, and being brave enough to let them show.


If you're ready to build a brand and website that carry what you stand for, I'd love to hear your story. You can schedule a free coffee chat, no pressure, or get a sense of how I think first with the story behind the studio.


Life is short. Don't wait to let your brand say what you believe.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page